MCFD to Deny Christmas Gifts to Children in Care?

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

My Response To The Ministry Of Child And Family Development’s Statement Regarding Gifts For Children

ParsingIsAsParsingDoes
DoesNotAlwaysResultInAStraightAnswerVille

Yesterday, in response to detailed information I received from a reader about a potential change to a longstanding practice at the Ministry of Child and Family Development (MCFD), I asked the following question of the Minister responsible and/or her boss:

Question #1: Have social workers in the MCFD been told they are not allowed to purchase Christmas gifts for the children and youth in government care? 

After a whole lot of follow-up, including Yaila Yuile’s direct enquiries, the Ministry released a statement that began like this:

“Any claim that the ministry will not be supplying Christmas gifts for children in care is absolutely inaccurate and it is very concerning that this erroneous message was sent to a client. In fact, social workers are encouraged to ensure every child and youth in care receives gifts during the holiday season…”

Now.

Notice that this did not answer my question.

Why?

Because, while ‘encouragement’ can be very helpful when there is another willing adult in the child’s life it is not the same as allowing the social workers to actually purchase a gift for the child if there is no such willing adult.

So….

What about Part 2 of the Ministry’s response:

“…Funding to cover gifts for children and youth in care is built-in to monthly payments the ministry sends to foster parents…”

Hmmmm.

This is strange because, based on the detailed information I received from my reader, I made it very clear that we were EXCLUDING kids in Foster care when we asked our question.

So, how about the third and final part of the Ministry’s response:

“…For children and youth living independently or on Youth Agreements, ministry staff are authorized and encouraged to ensure those young people are remembered over the holidays and gifts are provided.”

Well.

There’s that term ‘encouraged’ again. But, to be fair, there is also the term ‘authorized’.

But here’s the thing…..

The term ‘social worker’ (ie. the front-line folks I asked about specifically in my question) is no longer there for kids who are not in Foster care. Instead, the new term that has been inserted is ‘Ministry Staff’.

****

Now, why does any of this matter?

Because in many cases it is the front-line social workers who are able to build a direct adult relationship with those kids who are not in Foster care.

Thus, in my opinion they (i.e. the social workers) should be the ones making the purchases and giving the gifts.

And please remember, originally this was all raised in the context of budget-cutting in the MCFD given the government’s other spending priorities at the moment

****

Interestingly, there has been a bit of a backlash, particularly on Twitter, about the fact I first asked this question (as well as a direct follow-up question as well that you can find in the original post, here) and others, including Ian Reid, Norm Farrell, Paul Willcocks, NVG and Laila then commented on it.

Why?

Well, as near as I can figure it, it is all being dismissed as ‘irresponsible’ blogger blather.

But here’s the thing…

My reader is not the only person who has brought up this matter to the fore.

Specifically, a second source sent Laila an Email that corroborates what my reader had to say.

The text of that Email, with identifying addresses, etc., removed, goes like this:

“From: XXXXXX,XXXXX X MCF:EX [mailto:XXXXX.XX.X@gov.bc.ca]

Sent: December-03-12 3:03 PM

To: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX Subject: Christmas Gifts for XXXXXX

Please be advised that due to cutbacks, MCFD will not be supplying Christmas gifts for children in care.

As parents and extended family, you are still expected to provide a gift for your child if you wish to do so.

Thank you.

XXXXXXX XXXXXXX Child Protection Social Worker

Ministry of Children and Family Development “

So, in the face of material, some of it written, from two independent sources, is it still irresponsible to continue to ask the original question?

.

Posted by RossK at Wednesday, December 19, 2012 0 comments 

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

The Ministry Of Child And Family Development Responds…



Update: See Laila Yuile’s HuffPo piece….Here.

_____________
Breaking….

Laila Yuile has received a response to the Ministry that obliquely answers, for the record, Question #1 from our previous post.

The statement goes like this:

“Any claim that the ministry will not be supplying Christmas gifts for children in care is absolutely inaccurate and it is very concerning that this erroneous message was sent to a client. In fact, social workers are encouraged to ensure every child and youth in care receives gifts during the holiday season.
Funding to cover gifts for children and youth in care is built-in to monthly payments the ministry sends to foster parents. For children and youth living independently or on Youth Agreements, ministry staff are authorized and encouraged to ensure those young people are remembered over the holidays and gifts are provided.”

For context, here is our original question #1:

Question #1: Have social workers in the MCFD been told they are not allowed to purchase Christmas gifts for the children and youth in government care? 

****

Now, as I said, the Ministry’s statement was an oblique answer.

In the extreme.

Regardless, taken at face value it would appear to be case closed, right?

Except for the following…

I had a source that I used for my original post.

And Laila has one as well.

A source I mean, with evidence in writing.

The information from both sources is at odds with the Ministry’s statement of today.

I suggest you stay tuned to Laila for further developments (sorry have to go off to work for a few hours).

About these ads

About viewsofthechild

"In my respectful view all children in Canada have legal rights to be heard in all matters affecting them, including custody cases. Decisions should not be made without ensuring that those legal rights have been considered. These legal rights are based on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, (“the Convention”), and Canadian domestic law." Madam Justice D. Martinson, YKSC B.J.G. v. D.L.G., 2010 YKSC 44
This entry was posted in Ministry Children & Family Development BC and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to MCFD to Deny Christmas Gifts to Children in Care?

  1. LisaArlin says:

    Hey that statement is untrue by the Minister of MCFD
    DOES SO DENY CHILDREN CHRISTMAS PRESANTS.
    When your child is in care your denied christmas because office is not
    Open. More over I was granted a vist december 21 1999 child not delivered and when I asked if I could give presants to my child my request was denied as christmas presants are not considered a legal issue there for yoyr child is not getting presants from you the MCFD dont have the mandate to provide oresants to children who are in care they aren’t paid to provide . Mcfd arent legally obkugated to probidants or send them on be half of parents if mcfd is getting funding for christmas presants it is not being spent on presants. MCFD does not provide presants is left to the discretion of the foster parents who get paid to cloth and and feed the child but not to give christmas. I think it is just wrong any child be denied christmas with thier natural family or parent and for the sake of the childs well being provide them christmas. I dont see anything wrong with aporoved christmas visits with family who can supervise. Go figure this is the same MCFD that denies children to particapate in church and instead put them c in a prison not allowed out of office this abusive conduct by mcfd must be exposed McfdInjustice!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s